382. York Cocktail

 My interpretation:
  2 oz Cocchi Vermouth di Torino
  0.5 oz fresh lime juice with expended peel

Fill mixing-glass with cracked ice, shake, strain into cocktail glass, serve. — This simple Vermouth Service first appears in JM1912. The next year, Straub offers his version of the York, a Scotch-Vermouth duo with orange bitters shaken (aka Rob Roy Cocktail). Oddly enough, Straub’s recipe is the one found in The Old Waldorf Bar Days (1931), which seems to point to this as the original. Craddock’s York Special, however, is 1.5 oz Vermouth, 0.5 oz maraschino, and 4 dashes of orange bitters. Despite them all, Jack sticks to his Vermouth+lime recipe till the end.

371. Webster Cocktail

My interpretation:
  1 oz Plymouth Gin
  0.5 oz Martini & Rossi Extra Dry
  0.25 oz Rothman & Winter Orchard Apricot
  0.25 oz fresh lime juice

Shake well (30 seconds suffices to achieve good consistency, strain into cocktail glass, serve. —  The first thing to notice about this delicious Martini riff augmented by discreet portions of Apricot and lime, is that the math is all wrong. Jack may have meant percentages of 2 oz (a grown man’s drink), making this a larger drink than usual (i.e., 2.6 oz + dilution). However, I think it quite instructive to refer to the Savoy Cocktail Book (1930) here, the putative source, which calls for the proportion outlined above in my interpretation. This leads us to conclude that there is here a typo in the second line, and that apricot brandy should read 20%, not 50%. Of course, in type the characters are approximately mirrored along a horizontal axis. That would put us at 2 oz plus about 1 tsp., well within cocktail glass capacity of the time after dilution.

364. Waldorf Cocktail

My interpretation:
  1 oz Castle & Key London dry gin
  1 oz Kronan Swedish punsch
  1 tsp lemon juice
  1 tsp lime juice

Fill mixing-glass with ice, shake well (30-40 seconds), strain into cocktail glass, serve. —This Gin-Swedish Punsch Sour is one of several Waldorf cocktails preserved by Grohusko in JM 1916 and 1933 after Straub’s inclusion of them in 1913/1914. The same recipe appears in the Savoy Cocktail Book (1930). Curiously it does not appear in the Old Waldorf Bar Book (at least in the cocktail section).

323. Sidecar Cocktail

My interpretation:
  1 oz Copper & Kings brandy
  1 oz Cointreau
  3/4 T lime juice

In shaker with ice, add ingredients including half lime, shake well (30 seconds), strain into cocktail glass, serve. — This recipe from McElhone’s Barflies & Cocktails (1927) proved so popular, it had to be included in JM1933. There the recipe calls for equal thirds of cointreau (triple sec), cognac, and lemon juice, and is attributed to MacGarry of Buck’s Club, London. The Savoy (1930) Sidecar has twice the brandy but still lemon.
 

278. Pink Lady Cocktail

My interpretation:
  1 oz Aria American Dry Gin
  1 oz Laird’s Blended Applejack
  2 tsp Jack Rudy Grenadine / 1 tsp Rose’s Grenadine
  1 T fresh lime juice

Fill mixing-glass with ice, shake 30 seconds, strain into cocktail glass, serve. — This beguiling ride with a pretty paint job, Liquor in the front seat, and a Sour in the back, is first found in Straub 1913 and borrowed for JM1916. Barflies & Cocktails (1927) gives the recipe as brandy, gin, grenadine, and egg white (no lime juice). The Savoy (1930) version consists simply of gin, grenadine, and egg white without lime, applejack, or brandy. In all cases, as usual, the choice of grenadine, and its quantity, will require adjustment in order to obtain the proper color. In any event, you will want a color somewhere between the two examples below, with a flavor more approximating the first:

189. Jack Rose Cocktail

 My interpretation
  1.5 oz Daron calvados
  0.25 oz raspberry syrup
  0.25 oz barspoons lemon juice
  2 barspoons orange juice
  0.25 oz lime juice

Shake with cracked ice, strain, top up with cold soda water, serve. — This famous recipe is presented here in a slightly more involved, but worthwhile, form. As with the Clover Club, Jack calls for a mixture of citruses, which may reflect firs-thand knowledge of recipes used at the Waldorf or similar bars prior to his first publication in JM 1908. Calvados furnishes a drier effect, while Laird’s Bonded Apple Brandy provides more fruity apple flavor.

127. Emerson Cocktail

 My interpretation:
  1 oz Hayman’s Old Tom Gin
  0.5 oz Cocchi Vermouth di Torino
  0.5 oz fresh lime juice
  3 dashes Luxardo maraschino

Fill shaker with cracked ice, shake, strain into cocktail glass, serve. — Borrowed without change from Straub 1913 for JM 1916, this interestingly balanced mixture hovers between a Martinez and an Aviation, a sort of Martinez sour (as some have noted) which does best with a slightly bitter vermouth.

88. Clarendon Cocktail

 My interpretation:
  2 sprays of fresh mint
  1 T fresh lime juice
  2 oz Castle & Key London Dry Gin
  3 oz Reed’s Ginger Beer, chilled
  1 tsp sugar

In bottom of lowball or Old Fashioned glass mull (muddle) 1 spray of mint with sugar and a little hot water, add lime juice and gin, top up with ginger ale, stir slowly, carefully remove muddled mint and any loose leaves with cocktail fork, garnish with fresh mint sprig; serve. — This recipe is clearly out of place in the Cocktails section, and wants to be called a Clarendon Cooler. However, for the sake of Jack, I have endeavored to present it as a sort of cocktail. An explanation for the origin of the name is wanting; perhaps it is named for the venerable Clarendon Hotel in Quebec.

72. Cameo Kirby Cocktail

My interpretation:
  1.5 oz Bombay Sapphire
  1.5 oz Gallo Extra Dry
  2 tsp homemade raspberry syrup
  1 T fresh lime juice

Shake with ice, strain, and serve. — This recipe appears in JM 1916, having been published in Straub’s manuals of 1913/1914. It is named for a 1909 play by Booth Tarkington and Harry Leon Wilson that was also released as a film on Dec. 24, 1914. With correct preparation and fresh ingredients, this can be a pleasant drink.

58. Bronx Terrace

My interpretation:
  1.5 oz St. George Botanivore
  1.5 oz Dolin Extra Dry
  2 T fresh lime juice.

Fill mixing-glass with ice. Shake, strain, serve in cocktail glass. — Named for an area of the Bronx, New York, this cocktail, or rather Sour or Gimlet varaiation utilizing Dry Vermouth as mild sweetening agent and imitating a Bronx Dry with substitution of lime juice for orange (remember, the Bronx Dry does not appear in JM until 1916, and the Bronx before that has only an orange twist, not juice), first appears in Jack’s Manual 1908 and continues without change to the 1933 edition—contrary to some claims that it first appears in the 1930s. It may be that Jack picked it up, with several other recipes, from the Waldorf-Astoria, but that book was not published until after the Sad Era. Straub 1914 picks it up, omitting the cocktail glass and serve part in keeping with his usual abbreviated style. It also appears in the Savoy cocktail book (1930). The drink is bracing but tart, and remained a steady shower throughout the JM editions.

49. Bonnett Cocktail

This drink, properly a Sling rather than a Cocktail, seems to have been a house specialty at Baracca’s. It appears from the start in JM 1908 and continues to the end, though, unlike the Brooklyn Cocktail, it is not picked up by Straub. The 1933 recipe raises a few questions, for instance, the type of glass. This is answered by an instruction omitted after 1908:
 

Notice Ballor Vermouth is a sweet, not a dry as in the 1933 edition; in fact, all earlier editions call for some kind of Italian vermouth. Also, using a champagne glass, that is, something more ample than a 2-3 oz cocktail coupe, makes sense. The bowl of such a glass should be about 5-6 oz, and one should be able to stir the contents without difficulty or disaster, thus a thin punch glass or footed highball or small goblet as for a Singapore Sling.

My interpretation:
  2 T lime juice
  1.5 oz Benedictine
  1.5 oz Martini & Rossi Rosso
  
Build drink in glass with large ice cube, stir, top up with soda. Garnish with pineapple slice. 

47. Bogerz Cocktail

My interpretation:
  2.25 oz St. George Botanivore
  0.75 oz Martini & Rossi Extra Dry
  1 T fresh lime juice.

Fill mixing-glass with broken ice, stir, strain, serve. Garnish with half slice of lime. — This drink first appears in Jack’s 1910 manual. It differs from the Bronx Terrace in proportion and method of preparation (stirring instead of shaking).